Falling prices and faltering economy causes rise in mortgage delinquencies
What is new and unprecedented is the 11% delinquency rate we saw during the collapse of the housing bubble. For the last two years, this rate has been slowly declining, but it is still elevated well above historic norms.
Personally, I was not surprised to see the delinquency rate go back up as prices resumed their downward spiral. The weak economy was bound to cause an increase in delinquency, and coupled with strategic default from falling prices, higher delinquency rates are to be expected. Apparently, other economists completely missed these obvious signs.
By Eileen AJ Connelly, Associated Press — November 9, 2011
NEW YORK – While lawmakers in Washington debated the debt ceiling and consumer confidence dropped, more homeowners were having a harder time making their mortgage payments.
The rate at which mortgage holders were late with their payments by 60 days or more rose in the June-to-September period for the first time since the last three months of 2009, according to TransUnion.
The credit reporting agency said 5.88% of homeowners missed two or more payments, an early sign of possible foreclosure. That was up from 5.82% in the second quarter.
It isn’t a big increase, but any increase goes against the downward trend in place for the last two years.
The increase surprised TransUnion researchers, who had expected late payments, or delinquencies, to fall for the quarter.
“It’s much different than we’ve been talking about the last few quarters,” said Tim Martin, group vice president of U.S. Housing in TransUnion’s financial services business unit.
In other words, they blew it. They put on the happy-days-are-here-again goggles and saw what they wanted to see. They probably told all their clients things were getting better when in fact they weren’t.
The problems were widespread. Between the second and third quarters, all but 10 states and the District of Columbia saw delinquency rates increase.
TransUnion’s data is culled from 27 million credit reports, about 10% of U.S. consumers who actively use some form of credit.
Martin could not pinpoint one particular reason for the jump. Normally, for instance, housing prices and unemployment have a big influence on delinquency.
“Those are both still important, but neither has noticeably deteriorated,” he said. In fact, unemployment was steady during the summer and the Standard & Poor’s/Case-Shiller index showed small improvements in housing prices in most major cities during July and August.
Prices didn’t rise when they should have risen, and this fall and winter, they are plummeting. He missed the obvious.
That leaves wider economic issues having a larger role, Martin said. He pointed to the U.S. credit rating downgrade, the U.S. and European debt crises and the tanking U.S. stock markets during this period. And he noted that two different measures of consumer confidence — the Conference Board and the University of Michigan— both showed those issues hurt consumer attitudes.
That atmosphere “could make folks question paying their mortgage,” he observed, especially if they are under water, that is, they owe more than the house is now worth.
That’s nonsense. Does he really think someone, somewhere decided to stop paying their mortgage because the Greeks weren’t paying their bills? Give me a break. This is the kind of crap economists come out with when they don’t have a clue what they are talking about. It sounds plausible at first, but when you examine it closer, you realize it makes no sense at all.
Martin said there’s no real way to tell if some of the delinquency increase was driven by those under water. On the contrary, three of the 10 states that saw declines in late payments were among the hardest hit by the foreclosure crisis: Arizona, California and Nevada.
The decline in delinquency rates in those states is largely because the delinquent got foreclosed on. The rate of foreclosure exceeded the rate of fresh delinquencies. All of those states are non-judicial foreclosure states which weren’t impacted by robo-signer delays.
In fact, Arizona had the best rate of improvement in the nation, and now has a delinquency rate of 7.46%. That still places it fourth worst in the country, but the rate is vastly improved from where it stood. In the fourth quarter 2009, Arizona’s delinquency rate hit 16%, highest for any state since the foreclosure crisis began.
Arizona does, however, still have the highest foreclosure rate in the nation — one in every 44 housing units with a foreclosure filing in the third quarter, according to Realtytrac.
Another possibility for the bump in the delinquency rate is that a new crop of adjustable mortgages written toward the end of the housing bubble is resetting. Even if their interest rates remain low after the adjustment, payments might have increased, said Darren Blomquist, a Realtytrac spokesman. “We still have the bad loans mixed in that are resetting.”
Remember, it’s the recast to a fully amortized payment that causes the real payment shock. Even if interest rates are low, the conversion from interest-only to fully amortized is going to be a problem. The only reason this problem is not worse is because many of these people have already defaulted.
Although TransUnion still expects the delinquency rate to continue to fall in 2012, the company is now forecasting a few quarters of elevated nonpayment rates due to the uncertain economic outlook. The company doesn’t predict a return to the national peak rate of 6.9%, but said some increase is expected.
“More and more homeowners are likely to struggle,” Martin said. “I’m not sure this is a one-quarter blip.”
That echoes predictions from other sources, like RealtyTrac.
“This isn’t just about bad loans anymore,” said Blomquist. “It’s about a bad economy that’s pushing people into foreclosure.“